2.12 IPO/Initial Registration Statements
The reporting considerations in this section are unique to
situations in which financial statements of acquirees are required in an initial
registration statement. Since a company filing an initial registration statement has
not previously filed any financial statements with the public, it may find certain
parts of Rule 3-05 for
acquired businesses difficult to apply. For example, a new registrant would not have
been required to file a Form 8-K with audited financial statements of a significant
acquiree when the acquisition was consummated.
Registrants should also review the guidance in Deloitte’s Roadmap Initial Public Offerings and consider consulting with
their auditors and SEC legal counsel to determine the appropriate SEC reporting
requirements.
As discussed in Section 2.1, Rule 3-05 applies
to any acquisition of a business. However, the acquiree’s financial statements are
not required once the registrant’s audited financial statements reflect the
operating results of the acquiree for at least:
- Nine months if any of the results of the significance tests are greater than 20 percent but none are greater than 40 percent.
- A complete fiscal year if the results of any of the significance tests are greater than 40 percent.
A registrant is required to test the significance of acquirees only
during (1) the most recent full fiscal year presented in its audited financial
statements and (2) the subsequent interim period through the date the initial
registration statement is filed and declared effective by the SEC. As a result, the
registrant will not need to present the preacquisition financial statements for
acquisitions that occurred before the beginning of the most recent audited fiscal
year presented by the registrant (i.e., acquisitions that occurred in the
comparative fiscal years presented) unless the omission of such financial statements
would be misleading.
The table below summarizes whether
preacquisition financial statements are required for an acquiree on the basis of the
timing of the acquisition and the significance threshold.
Significance
|
Acquisition Closed Before the Most Recent Full Fiscal
Year Presented
|
Acquisition Closed During the Most Recent Full Fiscal
Year presented
|
Acquisition Closed After the Most Recent Full Fiscal
Year Presented
|
Probable Acquisition (Not Yet Consummated)
|
---|---|---|---|---|
Is 20 percent or less
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
Exceeds 20 percent but not 40 percent
|
No
|
If the acquisition closed during the fiscal
first quarter, no; otherwise yes. See Section 2.12.1 for further
details.
|
Yes — see Section 2.12.1 for further
details.
|
No — see Section 2.12.2 for further
details.
|
Exceeds 40 percent but not 50 percent
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes — see Section 2.12.1 for further
details.
|
No — see Section 2.12.2 for further
details.
|
Exceeds 50 percent
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
2.12.1 Grace Period
Financial statements of a significant acquired business that do
not exceed 50 percent significance (on the basis of any of the three
significance tests) are not required in a registration statement that is filed
or declared effective before the 75th day after the consummation of
the acquisition. (See the discussion of Company D in Example 2-53.) However, these requirements may be accelerated if
certain acquisitions are significant in the aggregate, as noted in Section 2.9. In addition,
the required financial statements and pro forma financial information must be
filed on Form 8-K within 75 days of the close of the transaction.
2.12.2 Aggregate
As discussed in Section 2.9, when filing a registration
statement, a registrant must evaluate the aggregate significance of (1) less
than 50 percent probable acquisitions; (2) greater than 20 percent, but less
than 50 percent, significant consummated acquisitions within the grace period;
and (3) any individually insignificant (20 percent or less) businesses acquired
since the end of the registrant’s most recently completed fiscal year presented.
2.12.3 Financial Statements Used to Measure Significance
Generally, in the determination of significance, the most recent
preacquisition annual financial statements of an acquiree are compared with a
registrant’s most recent preacquisition audited annual consolidated financial
statements (see Section
2.3.1).
Example 2-51
Registrant A acquired Company B on
December 15, 20X4; Company C on January 15, 20X5; and
Company D on July 15, 20X6. Registrant A and Companies
B, C, and D have December 31 fiscal year-ends.
Registrant A plans to file an initial registration
statement on September 15, 20X6. Significance should be
calculated for each acquisition as follows:
- Compare C’s financial statements for the fiscal year ended December 31, 20X4, with A’s audited financial statements for the fiscal year ended December 31, 20X4.
- Compare D’s financial statements for the fiscal year ended December 31, 20X5, with A’s audited financial statements for the fiscal year ended December 31, 20X5.
Registrants are required to test the
significance of acquirees only during (1) the most
recent full fiscal year presented in their audited
financial statements and (2) the subsequent interim
period through the date the initial registration
statement is filed and declared effective by the
SEC.
Because the acquisition of B occurred
before the most recent full fiscal year presented by A,
generally there is no requirement to test B for
significance.
In the case of a registrant that is conducting an IPO, we
understand that the SEC staff will not object if the registrant evaluates an
acquiree’s significance by using pro forma financial information that reflects
the effect of a prior significant acquisition (or disposition) consummated after the latest fiscal year-end for which its audited
financial statements are required to be presented and for which financial
statements of the prior significant acquiree and related pro forma financial
information are included in the registration statement. If the registrant
includes the financial statements and related pro forma financial information of
the prior significant acquiree in a draft registration statement, it must
ultimately provide them in a public filing as well. It would not be appropriate
to use pro forma financial information to evaluate the significance of an
acquiree if such information were only included in the draft registration
statement but not the registration statement that was publicly filed.
At the September 2021 CAQ SEC
Regulations Committee joint meeting with the SEC staff, the staff stated that a
registrant must meet the requirements of Regulation S-X, Rule 11-01(b)(3)(i)(B),
to use pro forma financial information when testing the significance of a
consummated acquisition.
A registrant must also consider the other conditions discussed in
Section 2.3.1.2 when using pro forma financial
information to evaluate the significance of an acquiree in an IPO/initial
registration statement.
Example 2-52
Company M, a non-EGC calendar-year-end company, intends
to submit a draft registration statement in July 20X9.
It reasonably expects to file publicly in November 20X9
and have its initial registration statement declared
effective in December 20X9.
On March 15, 20X9, M acquired Company N, a nonregistrant
whose fiscal year-end is also December 31. Because the
acquisition of N exceeds 20 percent, M will be required
to include separate audited financial statements of N
and the related pro forma financial information in its
draft registration statement and, ultimately, in a
public filing.
On June 15, 20X9, M acquired Company P, a nonregistrant
whose fiscal year-end is also December 31. To measure
the significance of the acquisition of P, M could use
either (1) the pro forma information as of and for the
year ended December 31, 20X8, that reflects the
acquisition of N that is expected to be included in a
draft registration statement in July 20X9 and publicly
filed in November 20X9 or (2) its historical audited
financial statements as of and for the year ended
December 31, 20X8, that did not reflect the acquisition
of N. Company M must use the option it elects for all
three significance tests. If it elects to use the pro
forma financial information, it must (1) prepare a pro
forma balance sheet as of December 31, 20X8, that
reflects the acquisition of N for use in the
determination of P’s significance and (2) continue to
use such information for future acquisitions and
dispositions until it files its first Form 10-K (i.e.,
for the year ending December 31, 20X9). On the basis of
the investment, asset, and income test, assume that the
highest level of the significance of the acquisition of
P is:
- Eighteen percent on the basis of M’s pro forma information as of and for the year ended December 31, 20X8, that reflects the acquisition of N.
- Twenty-three percent on the basis of M’s historical audited financial statements as of and for the year ended December 31, 20X8, that did not reflect the acquisition of N.
If M were to use its historical audited financial
statements, it would need to provide the separate
financial statements of P along with pro forma financial
information since the significance exceeds 20 percent.
However, because M elected to use its pro forma
information that reflects the acquisition of N, no
separate financial statements of P are required since
the significance of the acquisition of P does not exceed
20 percent.
If M’s IPO is delayed in such a way that M would be
required to provide its audited financial statements for
the year ended December 31, 20X9, when it first publicly
files its initial registration statement, the
significance of the acquisition of P must be evaluated
by using M’s historical audited financial statements for
the year ended December 31, 20X8. Company M is no longer
able to use its pro forma financial information because
the acquisition of P was not consummated after
the latest fiscal year-end for which M’s audited
financial statements are required to be presented (i.e.,
December 31, 20X9).
2.12.4 Periods of Preacquisition Financial Statements Required
If preacquisition financial statements are required, a
registrant determines the number of periods to provide on the basis of the
significance levels described in Section 2.3.
Example 2-53
Registrant A, a calendar-year-end company that does not
qualify as an EGC, is planning to file its initial
registration statement on or around September 15, 20X6.
It will provide its historical financial statements for
the following periods in its initial registration
statement:
- Audited balance sheets as of December 31, 20X5, and December 31, 20X4.
- Audited statements of operations, comprehensive income, cash flows, and changes in stockholders’ equity for each of the three years in the period ended December 31, 20X5.
- Unaudited financial statements as of and for the periods ended June 30, 20X6, and June 30, 20X5.
Registrant A made the following
acquisitions:
Company
|
Acquisition Date
|
Highest Level of Significance
|
Years Required
|
Financial Statements
Required*
|
---|---|---|---|---|
B
|
December 15, 20X4
|
60%
|
N/A
|
Because the acquisition of B occurred before
the most recent full fiscal year presented by A,
B’s preacquisition financial statements are not
required.
|
C
|
January 15, 20X5
|
55%
|
2
|
Because C has not been included in A’s audited
results for a complete fiscal year, A must provide
two years of preacquisition financial statements:
C’s financial statements as of and for the years
ending December 31, 20X4, and December 31,
20X3.
|
D
|
July 15, 20X6
|
25%
|
1
|
While one year of audited
financial statements will eventually be needed, as
of the initial filing date, no financial
statements of D are required on the basis of the
accommodation for recently consummated business
acquisitions, commonly referred to as the grace
period (see Section 2.12.1). In
any amendment to the IPO registration statement
filed 75 or more days after the consummation,
audited financial statements as of and for the
year ended December 31, 20X5, as well as unaudited
interim information as of and for the period ended
June 30, 20X6, would be required. In addition, if
A completes its IPO during the grace period, the
required financial statements and pro forma
financial information must be filed on Form 8-K
within 75 days of the close of the
transaction.
|
* Assumes that all acquired
companies are calendar-year-end companies and that
the registrant is not using the accommodation to
omit the acquiree’s balance sheet (see Section
2.12.5), when applicable.
|
Rule
3-06 permits the use of an acquiree’s audited financial
statements for a period of nine to twelve months to satisfy one year of
financial statement requirements. For example, for a transaction that closed in
the fourth quarter (e.g., November 15, 20X6) for which one year of audited
preacquisition financial statements is required, a registrant could provide
audited financial statements for the nine month period ended before acquisition
(e.g., the nine months ended September 30, 20X6) in lieu of audited financial
statements for the prior fiscal year (e.g., the year ended December 31, 20X5)
and unaudited information for the appropriate interim period (e.g., the nine
months ended September 30, 20X6).
2.12.5 Omitting a Balance Sheet for a Significant Business Acquisition
In accordance with Rule 3-05(b)(4)(iv), a
separate balance sheet of the acquiree is not required if the registrant’s most
recent audited balance sheet is for a date after the acquisition was
consummated. The registrant is still required to provide the acquiree’s
statements of operations, comprehensive income, and cash flows for the
appropriate periods.
Example 2-54
Registrant A acquired Company B on
December 15, 20X7. Both A and B have a December 31
fiscal year-end. The highest level of significance for
the acquisition of B was 35 percent. Registrant A plans
to file an initial registration statement in March 20X8
that will include A’s audited financial statements as of
December 31, 20X6 and 20X7, and for the three years
ended December 31, 20X7. Registrant A is required to
include B’s audited financial statements for one year in the initial
registration statement. See Section
2.3.
Because A’s audited balance sheet as of
December 31, 20X7, is for a date after the acquisition
was consummated, B’s balance sheet may be omitted.
Registrant A is still required to provide B’s statements
of operations, comprehensive income, and cash flows for
the appropriate periods.
2.12.6 Omitting Financial Statements of Acquired Entities From Draft Registration Statements
Historically, registration statements filed with the SEC were
immediately accessible to the public via EDGAR, the SEC’s online public
database. However, EGCs may confidentially submit certain IPO registration
statements to the SEC. In 2017, the SEC extended a similar benefit to non-EGCs,
allowing them to also voluntarily submit draft IPO registration statements to
the SEC staff for nonpublic review. See Section
1.4.2 of Deloitte’s Roadmap Initial
Public Offerings for a discussion of draft registration
statements and the nonpublic review process.
While each draft of a registration statement is generally
expected to contain all information required by SEC regulations, there is an
accommodation available to companies that allows them to omit acquiree financial
statements in certain circumstances. Specifically, under the accommodation, a
company may omit financial information from a nonpublic draft registration
statement for historical periods currently required if the company reasonably
believes that it will not be required to include these historical periods at the
time of the public filing (or, for EGCs, at the time of the contemplated
offering). Thus, a company may omit from its draft registration statement
Rule 3-05
financial statements (and the related pro forma financial information discussed
in Chapter 4) if
the company reasonably believes that those financial statements will not be
required at the time of the public filing (or, for EGCs, at the time of the
contemplated offering). See the SEC staff’s C&DIs on (1) Securities Act
Forms (Questions
101.04 and 101.05) and (2) the FAST Act (Questions 1 and 2).
Example 2-55
A calendar-year-end non-EGC registrant that plans to
submit an initial draft registration statement in the
fall of 20X7 completes a significant acquisition in the
fourth quarter of 20X6. The acquisition is significant
in such a way that one year of the acquiree’s financial
statements would generally be required under Rule 3-05.
The company plans to update its draft registration
statement to include its 20X7 annual financial
statements before a public filing in 20X8. Thus, after
that update, the acquired business will have been part
of the company’s financial statements for a sufficient
amount of time to eliminate the need for separate
financial statements. In this scenario, the CF-OCA will
not delay its review of the draft registration statement
in the fall of 20X7 even though the acquiree’s financial
statements and the related pro forma financial
information are omitted from the submission.
2.12.7 Waiver Requests Under Rule 3-13
When preparing an initial registration statement, a registrant
may wish to seek relief from complying with the various reporting requirements
under Regulation S-X, particularly those that are burdensome but may not be
material given the total mix of information available to investors. For example,
in an IPO, the registrant’s historical financial statements presented may
exhibit significant growth, but certain acquisitions may not be material to the
registrant’s current operations. If a registrant believes that as a result of
the literal application of the significance test it would be required to
provide, for an acquired business under Rule 3-05, financial statements that are
not material, not relevant, or not meaningful to investors, the registrant may
consider submitting — to the CF-OCA — a Rule 3-13 waiver request to omit or
substitute such financial statements. While recent changes to Rule 3-05 were
intended to modernize the requirements and are expected to reduce the number of
waivers, registrants may still seek modifications to their reporting
requirements under Rule 3-13 as the SEC staff continues to entertain these
requests. For more information, see Section 1.5.