3.13 Capitalization of Compensation Cost
SEC Staff Accounting Bulletins
SAB Topic 14.I, Capitalization of
Compensation Cost Related to Share-Based Payment
Arrangements
Facts: Company K is
a manufacturing company that grants share options to its
production employees. Company K has determined that the cost
of the production employees’ service is an inventoriable
cost. As such, Company K is required to initially capitalize
the cost of the share option grants to these production
employees as inventory and later recognize the cost in the
income statement when the inventory is
consumed.85
Question: If Company
K elects to adjust its period end inventory balance for the
allocable amount of share-option cost through a period end
adjustment to its financial statements, instead of
incorporating the share-option cost through its inventory
costing system, would this be considered a deficiency in
internal controls?
Interpretive
Response: No. FASB ASC Topic 718, Compensation —
Stock Compensation, does not prescribe the mechanism a
company should use to incorporate a portion of share-option
costs in an inventory-costing system. The staff believes
Company K may accomplish this through a period end
adjustment to its financial statements. Company K should
establish appropriate controls surrounding the calculation
and recording of this period end adjustment, as it would any
other period end adjustment. The fact that the entry is
recorded as a period end adjustment, by itself, should not
impact management’s ability to determine that the internal
control over financial reporting, as defined by the SEC’s
rules implementing Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of
2002,86 is effective.
__________________________________
85 FASB ASC paragraph
718-10-25-2A.
86 Release No. 34-47986, June 5,
2003, Management’s Report on Internal Control Over Financial
Reporting and Certification of Disclosure in Exchange Act
Period Reports.
While ASC 718 provides guidance on the measurement and recognition of share-based
compensation cost, it does not specify that all share-based compensation cost should
immediately be expensed. In certain cases, share-based compensation cost could be
capitalized on the basis of U.S. GAAP guidance such as the following:
- Inventory (ASC 330).
- Incremental costs of obtaining a contract with a customer and costs incurred in fulfilling a contract with a customer (ASC 340-40).
- Capitalized software costs (ASC 350-40 and ASC 985-20).
- Property, plant, and equipment (ASC 360).
If share-based compensation cost meets the criteria to be capitalized, the
capitalized amounts are subsequently accounted for in accordance with other
applicable GAAP. For example, share-based compensation cost may be capitalized as
internal-use software, which then would be subject to amortization requirements
under ASC 350-40 and impairment considerations under ASC 360.