7.1 Certain Transactions Involving Noncontrolling Interests

55-53 A controlling majority owner (parent) holds 80 percent of a subsidiary’s equity shares. The remaining 20 percent (the noncontrolling interest) is owned by an unrelated entity (the noncontrolling interest holder). Simultaneous with the acquisition of the noncontrolling interest, the noncontrolling interest holder and the parent enter into a derivative instrument that is indexed to the subsidiary’s equity shares. The terms of the derivative instrument may be any of the following:

1. The parent has a fixed-price forward contract to buy the other 20 percent at a stated future date. (Derivative 1)
2. The parent has a call option to buy the other 20 percent at a fixed price at a stated future date, and the noncontrolling interest holder has a put option to sell the other 20 percent to the parent under those same terms, that is, the fixed price of the call is equal to the fixed price of the put option. (Derivative 2)
3. The parent and the noncontrolling interest holder enter into a total return swap. The parent will pay to the counterparty (initially the noncontrolling interest holder) an amount computed based on the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), plus an agreed spread, plus, at the termination date, any net depreciation of the fair value of the 20 percent interest since inception of the swap. The counterparty will pay to the parent an amount equal to dividends paid on the 20 percent interest and, at the termination date, any net appreciation of the fair value of the 20 percent interest since inception of the swap. At the termination date, the net change in the fair value of the 20 percent interest may be determined through an appraisal or the sale of the stock. (Derivative 3)

55-54 If the terms correspond with Derivative 1, the forward purchase contract that requires physical settlement by repurchase of a fixed number of shares (the noncontrolling interest) in exchange for cash is recognized as a liability, initially measured at the present value of the contract amount; the noncontrolling interest is correspondingly reduced. Subsequently, accrual to the contract amount and any amounts paid or to be paid to holders of those contracts are reflected as interest cost. In effect, the parent accounts for the transaction as a financing of the noncontrolling interest and, consequently, consolidates 100 percent of the subsidiary.

55-55 Depending on how Derivative 2 was issued, one of three different accounting methods applies. If Derivative 2 was issued as a single freestanding instrument, under this Subtopic it would be accounted for in its entirety as a liability (or an asset in some circumstances), initially and subsequently measured at fair value. If the written put option and the purchased call option in Derivative 2 were issued as freestanding instruments, the written put option would be accounted for under this Subtopic as a liability measured at fair value, and the purchased call option would be accounted for under Subtopic 815-40. Under both of those situations, the noncontrolling interest is accounted for separately from the derivative instrument under applicable guidance. However, if the written put option and purchased call option are embedded in the shares (noncontrolling interest) and the shares are not otherwise classified as liabilities under the guidance in this Subtopic, the instrument shall be accounted for as discussed in paragraph 480-10-55-59 with the parent consolidating 100 percent of the subsidiary.

55-56 If the terms correspond with Derivative 3, the total return swap is indexed to an obligation to repurchase the issuer’s shares and may require the issuer to settle the obligation by transferring assets. Therefore it is in the scope of this Subtopic and is required to be accounted for as a liability (or asset in some circumstances), initially, and subsequently measured at fair value. The noncontrolling interest is accounted for separately from the total return swap.

55-57 In applying paragraphs 480-10-25-4 through 25-14 to determine classification, a freestanding financial instrument within this Subtopic’s scope is precluded from being combined with another freestanding financial instrument, unless combination is required under the provisions of Topic 815; therefore, unless under the particular facts and circumstances that Topic provides otherwise, freestanding derivative instruments in the scope of this Subtopic would not be combined with the noncontrolling interest.

55-58 This guidance is limited to circumstances in which the parent owns a majority of the subsidiary’s outstanding common stock and consolidates that subsidiary at inception of the derivative instrument. This guidance is limited to the specific derivative instruments described.

55-59 If the derivative instrument in Derivative 2 is embedded in the shares (noncontrolling interest) and the shares are not otherwise classified as liabilities under the guidance in this Subtopic, the combination of options should be viewed on a combined basis with the noncontrolling interest and accounted for as a financing of the parent’s purchase of the noncontrolling interest.

55-60 Under that approach, the parent would consolidate 100 percent of the subsidiary and would attribute the stated yield earned under the combined derivative instrument and noncontrolling interest position to interest expense (that is, the financing would be accreted to the strike price of the forward or option over the period until settlement). No gain or loss would be recognized on the sale of the noncontrolling interest by the parent to the noncontrolling interest holder at the inception of the derivative instrument.

55-61 The risks and rewards of owning the noncontrolling interest have been retained by the parent during the period of the derivative instrument, notwithstanding the legal ownership of the noncontrolling interest by the counterparty. Combining the two transactions in this circumstance reflects the substance of the transactions; that the counterparty is financing the noncontrolling interest. Upon such combination, the resulting instrument is not a derivative instrument subject to Subtopic 815-10.

55-62 This accounting applies even if the exercise prices of the put and call options are not equal, as long as those exercise prices are not significantly different.

The portion of equity (net assets) in a subsidiary not attributable, directly or indirectly, to a parent. A noncontrolling interest is sometimes called a minority interest.