4.6 Segment Reporting
The general framework of the segment reporting guidance in both IFRS 8
and ASC 280 is fundamentally the same in that both standards are built upon the
“management approach” and the determination of operating and reportable segments is
based on the same principles. Both IFRS 8 and ASC 280 require segment disclosures to be
based on the internal reports that the entity’s chief operating decision maker (CODM)
regularly reviews to allocate resources and assess performance. Before the adoption of
ASU 2023-07,
there were limited differences between certain segment disclosure requirements in IFRS
and U.S. GAAP. However, the ASU introduces several new disclosure requirements,
including those for significant segment expenses, other segment items, and CODM
disclosures, which are noted in the table below. In addition, the ASU expands the
disclosure requirements in interim financial statements and includes a requirement for
single reportable segment entities to provide all required segment disclosures. Further,
ASU 2023-07 permits the disclosure of more than one segment performance measure.
Topic
|
IFRS Accounting Standards (IFRS 8)
|
U.S. GAAP (ASC 280)
|
---|---|---|
Entity-wide disclosures of long-lived assets by geography
|
Noncurrent assets are defined as assets that do
not meet the definition of a current asset. Therefore, they
would include intangible assets.
|
Long-lived assets within the entity-wide disclosures do not
include intangible assets.
|
Entities with a matrix form of organization
|
An entity is required to identify operating
segments on the basis of the “core principle” regardless of the
form of organization used. Under IFRS 8, the core principle is
that operating segments must be identified in a manner that
enables users of the financial statements “to evaluate the
nature and financial effects of the business activities in which
[the entity] engages and the economic environments in which it
operates.” Management will therefore be required to exercise
judgment in determining which of the bases of segmentation
satisfies this objective.
|
An entity with a matrix form of organization is
required to determine operating segments on the basis of
products and services rather than on the basis of geographical
components or other information.
|
Aggregation disclosures
|
An entity is required to disclose the factors it used to identify
its reportable segments. There is no requirement to disclose the
judgments made by the entity in applying the aggregation
criteria.
|
An entity is required to disclose the factors it used to identify
its reportable segments and the judgments made by management in
applying the aggregation criteria.
|
Significant segment expenses
|
Identification and disclosure of significant segment expenses and
other segment items are not required.
However, paragraph 23(f) of IFRS 8 requires an entity to disclose
material items of income and expense that are disclosed in
accordance with paragraph 97 of IAS 1 if the items are either
(1) included in the measure of segment profit or loss reviewed
by the CODM or (2) otherwise regularly provided to the CODM,
even if not included in that measure of segment profit or
loss.
|
An entity is required to disclose significant segment expenses by
reportable segment if they are both (1) regularly provided to
the CODM and (2) included in each reported measure of segment
profit or loss. Disclosures are required on both an annual and
interim basis.
|
CODM-related disclosures
|
There are no specific CODM-related disclosure requirements.
|
An entity is required to (1) disclose the CODM’s title and
position on an annual basis and (2) provide an explanation of
how the CODM uses the reported measure(s) and other
disclosures.
|
Other segment Items
|
There is no specific guidance on other segment items other than
in paragraph 23(f) of IFRS 8.
|
ASC 280-10-50-26B requires entities to “disclose
for each reportable segment an amount for other segment items,”
which represents “the difference between reported segment
revenues less the segment expenses . . . and reported segment
profit or loss.”
The other segment items amount that must be
disclosed is calculated as segment revenue minus separately
disclosed significant segment expenses, minus the reported
segment profit or loss measure for each reportable segment.
Entities will need to provide a qualitative disclosure
describing the composition of such items.
|