On the Radar
Initial Public Offerings
After a record-breaking year for initial public offerings (IPOs) and
special-purpose acquisition companies (SPACs) in 2021, the market began slowing down
significantly in the first half of 2022 amid various challenges, including volatile
markets; geopolitical conflicts; inflation; supply chain issues; and COVID-19, which
continued to affect the global economy. In light of such challenges, private
companies continue to evaluate the methods used to go public. Such methods include a
“traditional” IPO, in which a private company sells its equity in a public
underwritten offering. However, over the past several years, nontraditional IPOs
have become more popular. Rather than undertaking traditional IPOs, many private
operating companies choose to merge with SPACs to raise capital or use other
financing alternatives, such as direct listings, which have also become more
frequent. Companies can also go public by registering debt securities, distributing
shares in a spin-off transaction, or registering securities issued by real estate
investment trusts (REITs).
Before a company commences a public offering of securities, it must file a
registration statement with the SEC under the applicable securities laws. Both the
form used to file the registration statement and the filing and review process will
depend on the nature of the offering. Companies undertaking a traditional IPO can
voluntarily submit a draft registration statement to the SEC staff for confidential,
nonpublic review. The ability to file confidentially is a significant benefit
because it allows companies to keep potentially sensitive information from customers
or competitors until later in the IPO process. Confidential initial submissions are
subsequently filed publicly no later than 15 days before (1) a roadshow or (2) the
requested effective date of the registration statement if no roadshow is
planned.
Once submitted to or filed with the SEC, a registration statement is
reviewed by the staff of the SEC’s Division of Corporation Finance (the “Division”),
which will generally complete its initial review and furnish its first set of
comments within 30 calendar days. The company then responds to each of the staff’s
comments and reflects edits to the draft registration statement in an amended
filing, which the staff will also review. A company can expect several rounds of
comment letters containing follow-up questions on responses to original comments as
well as additional comments on new information included in the amended registration
statement. After the initial review, subsequent comments are typically furnished
within two weeks. For more information about typical SEC staff comments, see
Deloitte’s Roadmap SEC Comment
Letter Considerations, Including Industry Insights.
Identifying the Required Financial Statements
A company must determine what financial statements are required in the
registration statement. While this determination may appear straightforward,
additional complexities may arise because a company may first need to determine
the legal entity that will become the SEC registrant. For example:
- A company may succeed to substantially all of the business of another entity (or the “predecessor”) for which financial statements are required.
- A company may be a carved-out entity that previously existed only as a subset of a larger parent entity or may be a combination of individual entities joined to form a larger public company.
- A company, a subsidiary, or a subset of subsidiaries may issue securities, guarantee securities, or otherwise have dividend restrictions that trigger requirements for the inclusion of separate financial statements or financial statement schedules in the IPO registration statement.
Further, a registrant may need to consider whether separate
financial statements or pro forma financial information is required for
“significant” business acquisitions, dispositions, or equity method
investments.
The financial statement periods to be included in the IPO registration statement
depend on the company’s characteristics and the timing of the document’s
submission. Smaller reporting companies (SRCs) and emerging growth companies
(EGCs) generally have the option of presenting only two years of audited annual
financial statements in a traditional IPO, while all other entities must present
three years. Further, under SEC regulations, the financial statements in an IPO
must meet certain age requirements as of each registration-statement filing date
as well as when the registration is declared effective; otherwise, the financial
statements will be considered “stale.” In general, the financial statements in
an IPO filing must not be more than 134 days old (i.e., the gap between the date
of filing or effectiveness and the date of the latest balance sheet cannot be
more than 134 days). However, third-quarter financial statements are considered
timely through the 45th day after the most recent fiscal year-end, after which
the audited financial statements for the most recent fiscal year are required.
Thus, a company that fails to file a registration statement before one of these
critical cut-off dates will be required to include additional financial
statement periods in the registration statement; in such cases, there may be a
significant delay in the company’s preferred IPO timeline.
A Public Entity’s Application of U.S. GAAP and SEC Regulations
Certain provisions of U.S. GAAP for public entities differ from those for
nonpublic entities. Notably, public business entities (PBEs) are generally
required to adopt new accounting standards before private companies. Although
companies that meet the EGC criteria can elect to use private-company adoption
dates for new accounting standards, other entities (i.e., non-EGCs) undertaking
an IPO typically must use public-company adoption dates for all accounting
standards.
In addition, a company undertaking an IPO must present financial
statements that are consistent with public-entity accounting principles and must
comply with the disclosure requirements for public entities for all periods
presented. The following are examples (not all-inclusive) of topics for which
the accounting principles or disclosures may apply to public entities but do not
apply to nonpublic entities:
-
Earnings per share.
-
Segment reporting.
-
Temporary equity classification of redeemable securities.
-
Certain income-tax-related disclosures.
-
Certain disclosures related to pensions and other postretirement benefits.
Once a company is
considered a PBE (even if it qualifies as an EGC and
elects to use private-company adoption dates), it is
no longer permitted to apply private-company
accounting alternatives, such as the amortization of
goodwill, or practical expedients permitted for
non-PBEs, such as use of a risk-free rate for
leases. Therefore, any previously elected
private-company alternatives or non-PBE practical
expedients would need to be retrospectively
eliminated from the company’s historical financial
statements before such statements can be included in
its registration statement.
Further, public entities are subject to various SEC rules and regulations that
may affect the financial statements and related disclosures (e.g., the
additional disclosure requirements of Regulation S-X). Some of these
requirements are broadly applicable, and some apply only to entities in certain
industries. Therefore, a nonpublic entity’s previously issued financial
statements will typically need to be revised for all periods presented to
reflect the additional SEC disclosure requirements. However, an entity that
meets the SRC criteria may be eligible to apply scaled disclosure requirements.
SRCs generally do not have to apply the disclosure provisions of Regulation S-X
in their entirety except when specified.
Audit Considerations for Public Companies
Audits of private companies are subject to AICPA auditing standards. However,
auditors of issuers undertaking an IPO must apply PCAOB auditing standards and
will need to perform additional procedures and issue a new auditor’s report that
refers to these standards. Note that in a filing submitted for
confidential review to the SEC, the auditor’s report will typically
refer to both AICPA and PCAOB auditing standards.
Because the SEC’s and PCAOB’s independence rules are generally more restrictive
than the AICPA’s, both the auditor and management, with oversight from the audit
committee, need to determine whether (1) there is possible noncompliance with
the SEC’s and PCAOB’s independence rules or (2) there are conflicts of interest
before the entity undertakes an IPO.
Post-IPO Periodic Financial Reporting and Internal Control Requirements
After a registration statement is declared effective, a company is required to
file quarterly reports on Form 10-Q and annual reports on Form 10-K. As a public
company, a registrant must also file a current report on Form 8-K that discloses
various material events that occur between its periodic reports.
A public company will need to address two types of controls and procedures in its
post-IPO filings with the SEC:
-
Internal control over financial reporting (ICFR) — ICFR refers to procedures a company performs to reasonably ensure compliance with its policies related to preparing financial statements in accordance with U.S. GAAP and Regulation S-X. Management must annually file a report on the effectiveness of its ICFR. Moreover, non-EGC accelerated and large accelerated filers must generally include an auditor’s attestation report on the effectiveness of ICFR in their annual reports. However, all new public companies can apply a phase-in exception under which management’s report and the auditor’s attestation are not required before the second annual report (i.e., until a registrant has been required to file or has filed a Form 10-K for the prior fiscal year). Certain additional exceptions may also apply.
-
Disclosure controls and procedures — These are a broader set of controls that largely encompass ICFR and are designed to provide assurance that information that the registrant must disclose in reports that it files or submits under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the “1934 Act”) is recorded, processed, summarized, and reported within the periods specified.
Companies also must continue to comply, on a quarterly basis, with reporting
requirements related to material changes to ICFR and disclosure controls and
procedures. In addition, in quarterly and annual reports, the registrant’s
principal executive and principal financial officer (typically the CEO and CFO)
must file certifications prescribed by Sections 302 and 906 of the
Sarbanes-Oxley Act.
SPAC Transactions
Over the past several years, SPAC transactions have increased
significantly. Management should be aware of the differences between a
traditional IPO and a SPAC transaction from a financial reporting and auditing
perspective. The table below outlines the areas of potential differences between
the two types of transactions.
Key Differences Between Traditional IPOs and SPAC
Transactions
|
---|
Financial statement periods required in the registration
statement/proxy statement
|
The ability to confidentially submit the registration
statement/proxy statement
|
The requirement to include pro forma information
|
The potential requirement to include prospective
financial information
|
The timing of the initial periodic reporting obligation
after the IPO or SPAC transaction
|
The reporting requirements related to ICFR
|
Deloitte’s Roadmap Initial
Public Offerings addresses
financial reporting, accounting, and auditing
considerations to help companies navigate challenges
related to preparing an IPO registration statement and
ultimately going public. Entities should also consider
Deloitte’s October 2, 2020 (updated April 11, 2022),
Financial Reporting Alert for
guidance on entering into a SPAC transaction as an
alternative to undertaking a traditional IPO, including
information about the SEC’s March 30, 2022,
proposed rule that is intended to
enhance disclosure and investor protections related to
SPACs.
Contacts
|
John Wilde
Partner
Deloitte &
Touche LLP
+1 415 783
6613
|
|
Previn Waas
Partner
Deloitte &
Touche LLP
+1 408 704
4083
|