1.1 Investments in Loans and Receivables
Under both IFRS Accounting Standards and U.S. GAAP, loans and
receivables are classified into categories that drive the measurement of these
instruments. However, there are significant differences between IFRS Accounting
Standards and U.S. GAAP in how these instruments’ classifications are determined.
Further, measurement differences exist because of these classification differences. The
table below summarizes the key differences in the accounting for investments in loans
and receivables under the two frameworks.
Topic
|
IFRS Accounting Standards (IFRS 9)
|
U.S. GAAP (ASC 310, ASC 326)
|
---|---|---|
Classification and measurement categories
|
Financial assets (except those for which the
fair value option (FVO) has been elected; see Section
5.5) are classified on the basis of both (1) the
entity’s business model for managing them and (2) their
contractual cash flow characteristics. Three classification
categories are used:
|
Generally, loan receivables are classified on
the basis of management’s intent as either held for sale (HFS)
or held for investment (HFI). Unless the FVO is elected (see
Section 5.5), loan
receivables are measured at either (1) the lower of cost or fair
value (for HFS loans) or (2) amortized cost (for HFI loans).
|
Recognition and measurement of impairment losses
|
Expected-loss approach — An impairment loss on a financial
asset accounted for at amortized cost or at FVTOCI is recognized
immediately on the basis of expected credit losses.
Depending on the financial asset’s credit risk
at inception and changes in credit risk from inception, as well
as the applicability of certain practical expedients, the
measurement of the impairment loss will differ. The impairment
loss would be measured on a discounted cash flow basis as either
(1) the 12-month credit loss or (2) the lifetime expected credit
loss.
Further, for financial assets that are credit impaired at the
time of recognition, the impairment loss will be based on the
cumulative changes in the lifetime expected credit losses since
initial recognition.
|
Current expected credit loss approach —
An impairment loss on a loan or receivable accounted for at
amortized cost is recognized immediately on the basis of
expected credit losses.
Entities have flexibility in measuring expected credit losses as
long as the measurement results in an allowance that:
Use of the discounted cash flow model is not
required.
|
Effective interest method
|
The effective interest rate is computed on the basis of the
estimated cash flows that are expected to be received over the
expected life of a loan by considering all of the loan’s
contractual terms (e.g., prepayment, call, and similar options)
but not expected credit losses.
Interest revenue is calculated on the basis of
the gross carrying amount (i.e., the amortized cost before
adjusting for any loss allowance) unless the loan (1) is
purchased or originated credit impaired or (2) subsequently
became credit impaired. In those cases, interest revenue is
calculated on the basis of amortized cost (i.e., net of the loss
allowance). If estimated receipts are revised, the carrying
amount is adjusted to the present value of the future estimated
cash flows, discounted at the financial asset’s original
effective interest rate (cumulative catch-up approach). The
resulting adjustment is recognized within profit or loss.
|
The effective interest rate is computed on the
basis of the contractual cash flows over the contractual term of
the loan, except for (1) certain loans that are part of a group
of prepayable loans and (2) purchased loans for which there is
evidence of credit deterioration. For purchased
credit-deteriorated assets, interest income is recognized on the
basis of the purchase price plus the initial allowance accreting
to the contractual cash flows.
If estimated payments for certain groups of
prepayable loans are revised, an entity may adjust the net
investment in the group of loans, on the basis of a
recalculation of the effective yield to reflect actual payments
to date and anticipated future payments, to the amount that
would have existed had the new effective yield been applied
since the loans’ origination/acquisition (retrospective
approach), with a corresponding charge or credit to interest
income.
|
Interest recognition on impaired loans
|
IFRS Accounting Standards do not permit
nonaccrual of interest. However, for assets that have become
credit-impaired, interest income is based on the net carrying
amount of the credit-impaired financial asset.
|
There is no explicit requirement in U.S. GAAP
for when an entity should cease the recognition of interest
income on a receivable measured at amortized cost. However, the
practice of placing financial assets on nonaccrual status is
acknowledged by U.S. GAAP.
|
Loan modifications
| A modification of the contractual cash flows of
a financial asset is accounted for by derecognizing the original
asset and recognizing a new asset if the modified terms are
substantially different from the original terms. If the
modified financial asset is accounted for as a new asset, a gain
or loss is recognized on the basis of the difference between (1)
the net carrying amount of the original asset and (2) the fair
value of the consideration received (including the fair value of
the modified asset). If the modified financial asset is
not accounted for as a new asset, a modification gain or
loss is recognized on the basis of the difference between (1) the
gross carrying amount of the original asset and (2) the present
value of the modified cash flows discounted by using the effective
interest rate of the original asset. | A loan
modification is accounted for as a new loan if both (1) the
terms are at least as favorable to the lender as the terms for
comparable loans to other customers with similar collection
risks (i.e., effective yield is at least equal to the effective
yield for comparable loans) and (2) the present value of the
cash flows under the modified terms is at least 10 percent
different from the present value of the remaining cash flows
under the original terms (i.e., the modification is “more than
minor”). If the loan is accounted for as
a new loan, any unamortized net fees or costs and any prepayment
penalties associated with the original loan are recognized in
interest income. If the loan is not accounted for as
a new loan, no gain or loss is recognized. |